Marketing Strategy
Jun 10, 2024

Agency vs. Freelancing: The Surprising Choice Business Owners Are Making to Boost Profits!

Agency vs. Freelancing: The Profitable Choice for Business Owners

Agency vs. Freelancing: The Surprising Choice Business Owners Are Making to Boost Profits!

In the digital age, Pay-Per-Click (PPC) advertising has become a cornerstone of many businesses' marketing strategies. PPC campaigns offer a targeted approach to reaching potential customers, driving website traffic, and generating leads. However, managing a successful PPC campaign requires expertise, time, and resources. Business owners often face the decision of whether to hire a PPC marketing agency or work with a freelance PPC specialist. Each option has its advantages and disadvantages, and understanding these can help business owners make informed decisions tailored to their specific needs and goals.

This article will explore the primary advantages and disadvantages of working with agencies versus freelancers. Our aim is to uncover key factors and insights prevalent in today's market, offering a comprehensive understanding of each option to help you make informed business decisions.

Advantages of Hiring a Marketing Agency

  • Comprehensive Expertise

PPC marketing agencies typically consist of teams with diverse skills and experience in various aspects of pay-per-click advertising. From keyword research and ad copy creation to campaign optimization and performance tracking, agencies offer comprehensive expertise across the entire PPC spectrum.

Example: For instance, a business launching a new product can benefit from an agency's ability to conduct thorough keyword research, craft compelling ad copy, and optimize campaigns for maximum ROI.

One of the primary drawbacks of hiring a PPC agency is the cost. Here are some general guidelines regarding PPC agency fees in the USA:

Flat Monthly Fee: Many agencies charge a flat monthly fee for PPC management services. This fee can range from $3,000 to $10,000 or more, depending on the complexity and scale of the PPC campaigns. By the way, our prices start at $2,000. For a detailed overview of our services and pricing structure, please visit our pricing page.

Percentage of Ad Spend: Some agencies may charge a percentage of the total ad spend as their fee. This percentage can vary but is typically in the range of 10% to 20% of the ad spend. For example, if a business spends $10,000 per month on PPC ads and the agency charges a 15% management fee, the agency fee would be $1,500 per month.

Performance-Based Fees: In some cases, agencies may offer performance-based pricing, where their fee is tied to specific metrics or outcomes, such as leads generated or sales conversions. This type of pricing structure can vary significantly depending on the agreed-upon performance goals and benchmarks.

Initial Setup Fees: Additionally, many agencies charge an initial setup fee to cover the costs associated with creating and optimizing PPC campaigns, setting up tracking and analytics systems, and conducting keyword research and audience targeting.

Example: A small business may find it challenging to afford the monthly management fees charged by a reputable PPC agency, particularly if they have a modest advertising budget.
  • Access to Advanced Tools and Technologies

PPC agencies often have access to sophisticated tools and technologies that can enhance campaign performance and efficiency. These tools include advanced analytics platforms, bid management software, and ad testing tools, which may be cost-prohibitive for individual businesses or freelancers.

Here are some of the most important:

Databox: This business analytics platform aggregates data from various sources into one interface, providing clients with real-time insights and customizable dashboards. It allows agencies to track key performance indicators (KPIs) across multiple data sources, such as Google Analytics, Facebook Ads, and Salesforce, enabling them to make data-driven decisions efficiently.

Overall, analytics tools play a vital role in PPC advertising by providing actionable insights into campaign performance, audience behavior, conversion tracking, attribution modeling, budget allocation, optimization opportunities, and performance reporting. By leveraging analytics data effectively, you can maximize the success of your PPC campaigns and achieve your marketing goals.

ClickCease: This software protects online advertising campaigns from click fraud. It monitors ad clicks, identifies a suspicious activity, and blocks fraudulent clicks in real-time to ensure advertisers get genuine traffic and maximize their ROI.

One interesting fact about ClickCease is that it uses advanced algorithms and machine learning to adapt and improve its fraud detection capabilities continuously. This means it can stay ahead of evolving click fraud tactics, providing advertisers with increasingly effective protection over time.

Mangools: This is a suite of SEO tools designed to help businesses improve their online visibility and rankings in search engine results. It includes tools for keyword research, rank tracking, backlink analysis, and competitor analysis.

Keyword research tools are essential for enhancing the effectiveness of PPC campaigns. They help you target the right keywords, understand user intent, estimate traffic and costs, analyze competition, expand your keyword portfolio, and optimize your ad copy and landing pages for improved performance.

  • Strategic Planning and Execution

Marketing agencies bring a wealth of experience and strategic insight to the table. They can devise long-term marketing plans that align with a company's overall business goals, ensuring cohesive and consistent messaging across all channels.

Example: An agency can develop a year-long content calendar that aligns with key business milestones and seasonal trends, ensuring that marketing efforts are timely and relevant.

Moreover, agencies often have established communication protocols and dedicated account managers, which facilitate better and more efficient communication with clients. This structured approach ensures that client feedback is systematically gathered and incorporated into the marketing strategy, leading to more effective campaigns and higher client satisfaction.

For example, using automation tools, we send a daily email to clients with all key performance metrics.

Regular updates, meetings, and detailed reporting keep clients informed about progress and outcomes, fostering a collaborative partnership and enabling swift adjustments to strategies as needed. This enhanced communication framework helps in anticipating client needs, addressing concerns promptly, and maintaining a clear and consistent flow of information between the agency and the client.

Advantages of Hiring a Freelancer

Before delving into the advantages of hiring freelancers, let's first establish what freelancing entails. Freelancing refers to a work arrangement where individuals offer their skills and services on a project or contractual basis, rather than being employed full-time by a single organization. This setup allows freelancers to work for multiple clients simultaneously, providing them with the flexibility to diversify their income sources and engage in a variety of projects.

Looking ahead, forecasts paint a promising picture for the freelance market, with projections indicating a significant growth trajectory. By 2023, the market is expected to surpass $455.2 billion, with further projections exceeding $500 billion by 2024. This exponential rise highlights the expansive potential within the freelance sector, offering a lucrative landscape for aspiring freelancers to explore.

In 2020, a staggering 59 million Americans embraced freelance work, comprising a formidable 36% of the nation's workforce. This statistic underscores the substantial economic contribution made by freelancers, reflecting a growing preference for adaptable work structures among individuals.

The most sought-after freelance skills include web development, mobile app development, and graphic design. This heightened demand underscores the critical importance of honing and refining these proficiencies to maintain a competitive edge within the freelance marketplace.

Below are the current prices for Google Ads management services on the Fiverr platform:

Hiring a freelancer can be a highly cost-effective solution for businesses, offering not only financial savings but also access to a diverse pool of talent.

  • Cost-Effectiveness vs. Resource Constraints

Freelancers typically offer more competitive rates compared to marketing agencies, making them an appealing choice for small businesses or startups with limited budgets. This financial advantage allows these businesses to allocate funds more efficiently and invest in other critical areas of growth.

Example: A startup might engage a freelancer to manage their social media accounts at a significantly lower cost than hiring an agency.

Conversely, freelancers may not have access to the sophisticated tools and technologies that agencies can leverage. This limitation can affect the quality and efficiency of their work, potentially leading to suboptimal outcomes.

While the cost savings associated with hiring a freelancer can be substantial, businesses need to carefully consider whether these savings justify the potential trade-offs in resource quality. For some businesses, the lower cost represents a major benefit; for others, the absence of advanced tools and technologies could impede performance and desired results.

  • Direct Communication vs. Reliability and Consistency

Engaging with a freelancer facilitates direct and streamlined communication, which can reduce misunderstandings and ensure quicker response times. This direct line of communication allows for a more agile and responsive approach to making adjustments and addressing concerns. A business owner can directly communicate with the freelancer to discuss campaign adjustments, resulting in faster implementation of changes.

On the downside, freelancers may not always provide the same level of reliability and consistency as agencies. Factors such as personal issues, workload fluctuations, and the absence of formal accountability mechanisms can negatively impact their performance. A freelancer dealing with personal challenges might miss deadlines or fail to deliver the expected quality of work, thereby affecting the business’s marketing efforts.

The advantage of direct communication enhances efficiency and responsiveness, making it easier to quickly adapt strategies and implement changes. However, businesses must weigh this benefit against the potential for inconsistency and unreliability. To mitigate these risks, it is crucial to establish clear expectations, set up robust communication channels, and implement regular check-ins to monitor progress. In our agency, we utilize two primary communication channels: email and Slack. These platforms are integrated with various automated rules for notifications and alerts pertaining to advertising campaigns, which enhances the transparency of communication between our agency and the client. Below are example of widgets with notifications in our Slack channels.

  • Knowledge Expertise vs. Comprehensive Verification

While the specialized knowledge and expertise of freelancers can significantly enhance specific business functions, verifying the credibility and background of freelancers is essential to ensure they meet the required standards. This has become increasingly challenging due to the proliferation of unqualified individuals posing as experts in the freelance market. Many freelancers may present polished portfolios and compelling testimonials that are difficult to authenticate.

Thorough Vetting Process: Implementing a comprehensive vetting process can help mitigate the risk of hiring unqualified freelancers. This includes conducting in-depth interviews, requesting detailed work samples, and seeking out multiple references from previous clients.

Trial Projects: Offering a small, paid trial project can be an effective way to assess a freelancer’s capabilities before committing to a larger engagement. This allows businesses to evaluate the quality of work, adherence to deadlines, and overall professionalism.

Reputable Platforms: Utilizing reputable freelance platforms that have robust verification processes and ratings systems can also help in finding reliable freelancers. These platforms often include feedback and ratings from previous clients, which can provide additional assurance of the freelancer’s qualifications and reliability.

For exemple, Fiverr Pro is a premium service on Fiverr, offering high-quality freelance services from top-tier professionals. It's a selective platform where experienced freelancers undergo rigorous vetting. Clients benefit from working with experts in fields like design, writing, and marketing, ensuring premium results. Though rates may be higher, clients receive personalized attention and top-notch deliverables. Overall, Fiverr Pro provides a reliable platform for accessing elite freelance talent.

Professional Networks: Leveraging professional networks and referrals can also be valuable. Recommendations from trusted industry peers can often lead to finding highly skilled and reliable freelancers.

So, let's summarize.

When it comes to deciding between hiring a marketing agency or a freelancer, several factors come into play, including budget, scope of work, desired level of control, long-term objectives, and the quality and reliability of potential candidates. Each option presents its own set of advantages and disadvantages, and the optimal choice varies depending on the unique needs and circumstances of each business.

Here's a breakdown of key considerations to aid in the decision-making process:

1. Budget

Start by evaluating the available budget for marketing services. Marketing agencies typically require a larger financial investment, while freelancers may offer more budget-friendly rates. However, it's crucial to assess the cost in relation to the anticipated value and return on investment (ROI).

2. Scope of Work

Next, define the scope of marketing activities required. For extensive, multi-channel campaigns, an agency with its broad expertise and resources may be more suitable. Conversely, for specialized or smaller-scale projects, a freelancer might offer a better fit.

3. Desired Level of Control

Consider the preferred level of control and involvement in the marketing process. Business owners who wish for direct engagement and communication may lean towards hiring a freelancer, whereas those comfortable with delegating responsibilities may opt for an agency.

4. Long-Term Goals

Assess the long-term marketing objectives of the business. Agencies can provide strategic planning and scalability, which are beneficial for sustained growth. On the other hand, freelancers, with their flexibility and specialized skills, may be ideal for specific, short-term projects.

5. Quality and Reliability

Research the track record and reliability of potential agencies and freelancers. Seek out client testimonials, case studies, and portfolio examples to gauge the quality of work and reliability.

Ultimately, business owners should carefully evaluate their specific requirements, resources, and goals to make an informed decision aligned with their overall marketing strategy and business objectives. By doing so, they can optimize the effectiveness of their marketing endeavors and achieve sustainable growth and success.

Evgeniy Bokhan

Evgeniy Bokhan is the visionary Founder & CEO of a dynamic company, leading a team of experts to redefine industry standards.

Subscribe to our newsletter

Subscribe to our newsletter for meticulously curated, top-notch content delivered directly to your inbox.